Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Meenu Sarin's avatar

Your point of inference becoming the real cash cow of AI infrastructure is spot on. When you're serving tokens at scale, unit economics are everything.

From an engineer’s perspective, what Etched is doing with Sohu is fascinating. Burning Transformer primitives directly into static silicon bypasses all the scheduling, decoding, and dispatch tax you pay on GPUs, gives you incredible FLOPS/Watt and absurd throughput. For high-volume, steady-state workloads today, it's easily one of the most aggressive and elegant hardware designs out there.

However, the structural risk here is massive: Etched is betting the entire farm on the Transformer architecture staying king forever.

The cardinal rule of fixed-function ASICs is speed is a function of rigidity. The moment you hardwire logic to maximize efficiency, you trade away your ability to pivot.

Look at where AI research is heading:

• We’re seeing a real push toward linear-time attention and State Space Models (like Mamba or RWKV) to beat the memory wall of giant KV caches.

• Newer paradigms like Test-Time Training (TTT) are experimenting with dynamic weight updates during inference itself.

Etched’s counter-argument is usually that they support "hybrid" models (like pairing Transformer blocks with Mamba or MoE). But "hybrid ASIC support" isn't the same thing as general-purpose flexibility. If the AI research community invents a completely new mathematical primitive or changes how context state is handled next year, you can't patch static silicon with a software update; you’re looking at a multi-million dollar tape-out and a new chip cycle.

Ultimately, enterprise buyers and hyperscalers are facing a classic hardware trade-off:

Do you buy Etched for unmatched throughput on today’s Transformer models, or do you stick with NVIDIA GPUs / Groq and other AI inference ASICs as an insurance policy against algorithmic drift?

Etched built a Ferrari for the Transformer era and it's going to crush benchmarks today. But in an industry where state-of-the-art model architectures shift every six months, hardwiring your silicon to a single model paradigm looks to be a high-stakes gamble.

Grish Ram's avatar

“Production is the product” feels right. A faster chip matters less if memory, cooling, power or software becomes the constraint. Real-world tokens per watt will tell us more than peak specifications.

No posts

Ready for more?