Will disagree with the premise, as a practising physician the answer in unlikely on the records, medical records are notoriously, incomplete, and inaccurate. Training a model on medical records will result in one optimized to maximizing billing and minimizing liability instead of getting to the truth of clinical decision making.
We can also simply have multiple correct answers.
I think there is a massive sunken cost fallacy in healthcare where just because we have collected so much data that this data must inherently be valuable. This is not necessarily true.
While medical records contain a vast amount of information, my clinical intuition is, they did not contain the information needed to replicate the work we do.
As the leading dental implant surgeon and Ai-Driven technology expert, I TOTALLY agree with Bobby and Engy on this one. This essay is a great synopsis illustrating the kludgy world of surgical healthcare. I know 1,000s of surgeons and they typically do what they are good at and limit what they are not good at. "To a kid with a hammer everything is a nail."
This is also sooo true in the world of dental implants and it DOES NOT serve the patient well at all. We should do better
At Whitefield BioMed, our Magnum Opus is to change this archaic, Luddite-fueled philosophy of healthcare and increase everyone's longevity through proper, effective oral medicine.
Sorry to say this out loud, but the M.D.s need to catch upon this one. Don't be an Anti-Dentite!
The hemorrhage example is the one I keep chewing on. A physician's next decision shifts because the last delivery went badly — yet the record files each case as its own row. So the label isn't only one surgeon's taste versus another's; it can be the same surgeon's taste a few days earlier. A model graded on that may learn medicine, or learn the mood of the ward, and the benchmark can't say which.
I get much more salient and understandable help from chatGPT on health issues, supplement issues, analyzing tests and so on that I have ever received from any other human MD, and I have been a patient at Stanford, UCSF, PAMF and a few others.
At least with chatGPT, when I ask a question, I ALWAYS get an answer that is at least marginally helpful.
OTOH, when I have tried to drill into an issue with an MD, assuming they have the time to give me before rushing to the next appointment that they are late for, their standard reply is often, "don't worry about it. It's not a problem." as they hurry out the door with a "nice to see you " and a wave.
And I have yet to encounter an MD who actually takes the time to read my patient record prior to the consult. 99% of the time I'll get a "so what brings you in today?" and I wonder why/if the scheduler didn't update the initial contact record and why I have to rehash what my problem is?
When I was a corporate worker in the sales arena, I ALWAYS spent 5-10 mins prior to any call refreshing my/our last contact with the prospect/customer to see what issues were outstanding, so we could have an informed discussion from the beginning. MD's refuse to do this, wasting both the patients and their own limited time.
Excellent article!! Very insightful critique of the way AI tools as currently developed/deployed in clinical settings or test beds will ultimately fail patients. Like clinical care algorithms today, they seem to be skewing toward solutions that provide “least common denominator” insights, recommendations or options. Yet, the hype that we’re being sold suggests AI will do the exact opposite. This has been one of my big “fears” for AI for many years.
Will disagree with the premise, as a practising physician the answer in unlikely on the records, medical records are notoriously, incomplete, and inaccurate. Training a model on medical records will result in one optimized to maximizing billing and minimizing liability instead of getting to the truth of clinical decision making.
We can also simply have multiple correct answers.
I think there is a massive sunken cost fallacy in healthcare where just because we have collected so much data that this data must inherently be valuable. This is not necessarily true.
While medical records contain a vast amount of information, my clinical intuition is, they did not contain the information needed to replicate the work we do.
A real problem, oversold
As the leading dental implant surgeon and Ai-Driven technology expert, I TOTALLY agree with Bobby and Engy on this one. This essay is a great synopsis illustrating the kludgy world of surgical healthcare. I know 1,000s of surgeons and they typically do what they are good at and limit what they are not good at. "To a kid with a hammer everything is a nail."
This is also sooo true in the world of dental implants and it DOES NOT serve the patient well at all. We should do better
At Whitefield BioMed, our Magnum Opus is to change this archaic, Luddite-fueled philosophy of healthcare and increase everyone's longevity through proper, effective oral medicine.
Sorry to say this out loud, but the M.D.s need to catch upon this one. Don't be an Anti-Dentite!
The hemorrhage example is the one I keep chewing on. A physician's next decision shifts because the last delivery went badly — yet the record files each case as its own row. So the label isn't only one surgeon's taste versus another's; it can be the same surgeon's taste a few days earlier. A model graded on that may learn medicine, or learn the mood of the ward, and the benchmark can't say which.
Invisible bottlenecks decide who compounds. The scarce edge is deciding which parts-and-power assumptions still deserve capital.
https://paretoinvestor.substack.com/p/electron-is-the-new-oil
I get much more salient and understandable help from chatGPT on health issues, supplement issues, analyzing tests and so on that I have ever received from any other human MD, and I have been a patient at Stanford, UCSF, PAMF and a few others.
At least with chatGPT, when I ask a question, I ALWAYS get an answer that is at least marginally helpful.
OTOH, when I have tried to drill into an issue with an MD, assuming they have the time to give me before rushing to the next appointment that they are late for, their standard reply is often, "don't worry about it. It's not a problem." as they hurry out the door with a "nice to see you " and a wave.
And I have yet to encounter an MD who actually takes the time to read my patient record prior to the consult. 99% of the time I'll get a "so what brings you in today?" and I wonder why/if the scheduler didn't update the initial contact record and why I have to rehash what my problem is?
When I was a corporate worker in the sales arena, I ALWAYS spent 5-10 mins prior to any call refreshing my/our last contact with the prospect/customer to see what issues were outstanding, so we could have an informed discussion from the beginning. MD's refuse to do this, wasting both the patients and their own limited time.
Excellent article!! Very insightful critique of the way AI tools as currently developed/deployed in clinical settings or test beds will ultimately fail patients. Like clinical care algorithms today, they seem to be skewing toward solutions that provide “least common denominator” insights, recommendations or options. Yet, the hype that we’re being sold suggests AI will do the exact opposite. This has been one of my big “fears” for AI for many years.