The federal government was not the federal Government of today. People back then were sturdy and hungry. They were built to work. Now folks are built not to work... Post WW2. Now it seems people are useless and all of the infrastructure could not be built now. Folks couldn't do it....
Conditions are the same? If you read old books you can see that people have been pretty much the same since the dawn of civilization, but I think I get what your saying, there’s a lack of trades like cobblers, an obesity epidemic, maybe a sensitivity epidemic resulting in less capable people partly due to over medication and coddling. Litigation and workers rights have a lot to do with this. But we also have technology on our side now. But it does seem the main thing between how people live now and in Victorian times are conditions
I will make it easy for you. I wrote a book proving that people are the same; conditions change: "Can America ever be great again?" I is available everywhere books are sold. Prove me wrong.
The Arizona copper mine is the example that keeps sticking with me. A deposit that could cover a quarter of U.S. copper demand, found in 1995 and still staring at a 35-year path to production, matters a lot more now that copper runs through every data center, grid upgrade and defense supply chain. China refines most of the world's copper and has spent years locking up mines abroad, so every year an American project sits idle hands Beijing a little more leverage. The Noe Valley toilet gets the laughs, but the transmission line that took two years to build and fifteen to litigate might be the more telling number. Curious which reform you think has the best odds with the new Congress, since permitting is one of the few areas where both parties have at least talked about a deal.
The solution needs to address lawsuits intentionally used to block projects, or worse, fundraising tools for nonprofits’ justification of existence. I’ve always said “ it it’s going to be built anyways, might as well eliminate the barriers.”
The Gotthard Base Tunnel coming in a year early is a good one to put next to the high speed rail numbers, and it's a nice change from the usual line that Europe can't build anything, the European examples are doing a lot of the work in this argument. I'd love to see the same comparison done for grid connections because that five year queue seems to be the thing holding up everything else.
Excellent piece. The question that it beggs is who benefits from these delays? If you want to understand a behavior, look at the incentives. In this case it could be avoiding negative incentives -- the threat of lawsuit. China is run by engineers, the United States by Lawyers. I had a book on my reading list. : Breakneck: China's Quest to Engineer the Future by Dan Wang. Your article just gave me the nudge to actually read it. Something is very wrong here and maybe we an learn from China.
I love that we've reached a point where building a public toilet apparently requires the organisational sophistication of a space programme. And somehow, the toilet is still the difficult part.
Permitting gets the blame and it deserves a lot of it. But the Empire State Building went up fast for another reason too. The steel was designed and fabricated and delivered on a schedule tighter than most of today's concrete pours. Speed was engineered into the method before a single beam arrived. We see the same thing in India. Fix permits and you still need builders who plan for speed from day one.
Good piece, Matt. This hits on the exact problem: we have replaced actual building with endless paperwork. Investors can budget for a $6.6 million environmental study, but they cannot budget for delays that have no end in sight. When lawsuits and five-year wait times to connect to the power grid drag projects out indefinitely, the risk becomes impossible to calculate, killing good projects before they even start.
This gridlock keeps happening because of backwards incentives. A company board would fire a CEO who lets vital projects sit stalled for a decade. In Washington, however, politicians and regulators get blamed if a project they approve goes wrong, but face zero consequences when a project dies from delay. Red tape becomes an easy way to avoid responsibility.
The 2026 permitting reforms—strict deadlines, a single review process, and stopping lawsuits over minor paperwork mistakes—bring back the one thing builders need most: certainty. Rebuilding America means judging agencies and lawmakers by real results—on the roadblocks they clear and the projects they actually finish, not the paperwork they create.
Fast. 2 years in fact. Team DEMolition just picked up 85 electoral votes and the Arizona method of she who counts the votes will be rewarded with future Governor.
How much did the federal government contribute to the construction of the Empire State Building and the Golden Gate Bridge?
BTW, my new book, "Can America ever be great again?" takes an engineer's approach to the problems discussed in the essay above.
The federal government was not the federal Government of today. People back then were sturdy and hungry. They were built to work. Now folks are built not to work... Post WW2. Now it seems people are useless and all of the infrastructure could not be built now. Folks couldn't do it....
People are always the same. Conditions changed.
I disagree with you that people are the same. Definitely conditions are the same. This is a great debate potential. Thanks for the comment
Conditions are the same? If you read old books you can see that people have been pretty much the same since the dawn of civilization, but I think I get what your saying, there’s a lack of trades like cobblers, an obesity epidemic, maybe a sensitivity epidemic resulting in less capable people partly due to over medication and coddling. Litigation and workers rights have a lot to do with this. But we also have technology on our side now. But it does seem the main thing between how people live now and in Victorian times are conditions
I will make it easy for you. I wrote a book proving that people are the same; conditions change: "Can America ever be great again?" I is available everywhere books are sold. Prove me wrong.
The Arizona copper mine is the example that keeps sticking with me. A deposit that could cover a quarter of U.S. copper demand, found in 1995 and still staring at a 35-year path to production, matters a lot more now that copper runs through every data center, grid upgrade and defense supply chain. China refines most of the world's copper and has spent years locking up mines abroad, so every year an American project sits idle hands Beijing a little more leverage. The Noe Valley toilet gets the laughs, but the transmission line that took two years to build and fifteen to litigate might be the more telling number. Curious which reform you think has the best odds with the new Congress, since permitting is one of the few areas where both parties have at least talked about a deal.
Matt,
The solution needs to address lawsuits intentionally used to block projects, or worse, fundraising tools for nonprofits’ justification of existence. I’ve always said “ it it’s going to be built anyways, might as well eliminate the barriers.”
Yea litigation #1 problem - how does that get fixed
The Gotthard Base Tunnel coming in a year early is a good one to put next to the high speed rail numbers, and it's a nice change from the usual line that Europe can't build anything, the European examples are doing a lot of the work in this argument. I'd love to see the same comparison done for grid connections because that five year queue seems to be the thing holding up everything else.
Excellent piece. The question that it beggs is who benefits from these delays? If you want to understand a behavior, look at the incentives. In this case it could be avoiding negative incentives -- the threat of lawsuit. China is run by engineers, the United States by Lawyers. I had a book on my reading list. : Breakneck: China's Quest to Engineer the Future by Dan Wang. Your article just gave me the nudge to actually read it. Something is very wrong here and maybe we an learn from China.
I love that we've reached a point where building a public toilet apparently requires the organisational sophistication of a space programme. And somehow, the toilet is still the difficult part.
Permitting gets the blame and it deserves a lot of it. But the Empire State Building went up fast for another reason too. The steel was designed and fabricated and delivered on a schedule tighter than most of today's concrete pours. Speed was engineered into the method before a single beam arrived. We see the same thing in India. Fix permits and you still need builders who plan for speed from day one.
I still have the American Dream.
excellent article and I hope makes people pause.
Good piece, Matt. This hits on the exact problem: we have replaced actual building with endless paperwork. Investors can budget for a $6.6 million environmental study, but they cannot budget for delays that have no end in sight. When lawsuits and five-year wait times to connect to the power grid drag projects out indefinitely, the risk becomes impossible to calculate, killing good projects before they even start.
This gridlock keeps happening because of backwards incentives. A company board would fire a CEO who lets vital projects sit stalled for a decade. In Washington, however, politicians and regulators get blamed if a project they approve goes wrong, but face zero consequences when a project dies from delay. Red tape becomes an easy way to avoid responsibility.
The 2026 permitting reforms—strict deadlines, a single review process, and stopping lawsuits over minor paperwork mistakes—bring back the one thing builders need most: certainty. Rebuilding America means judging agencies and lawmakers by real results—on the roadblocks they clear and the projects they actually finish, not the paperwork they create.
"Adequately staff permitting personnel"
That.
By deleting permitting personnel….except for legit safety and environmental considerations
Fast. 2 years in fact. Team DEMolition just picked up 85 electoral votes and the Arizona method of she who counts the votes will be rewarded with future Governor.
2 years. ⏱️
Can't imagine which political party by and large causes this mess?
The Whigs?
The Federalists?
Not the libertarians…
Well, that's one political movement/party not cauisng all this.